| Alley | Hip | Athlete | Team | Seed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1A | 3 | SCHURR, Eve | Avon | 2:25.59 |
| 1B | 7 | FORD, Vivian | Avon | 2:35.00 |
| 1C | 11 | JOHNSON, Sandra | Pike | NT |
| 2A | 1 | PEREGO, Caterina | Homestead | 2:19.96 |
| 2B | 5 | MITCHELL, Callie | Carroll (Fort Wayne) | 2:32.00 |
| 2C | 9 | RAUH, Sadie | Pendleton Heights | 2:39.04 |
| 3A | 2 | ZOELLER, Anya | Pendleton Heights | 2:23.48 |
| 3B | 6 | EVANS, Cora | Carroll (Fort Wayne) | 2:33.00 |
| 3C | 10 | JACKSON, Keira | Jeffersonville | NT |
| 4A | 4 | LEBRIJA, Clare | Homestead | 2:26.63 |
| 4B | 8 | SUCHECKI, Georgia | Pike | 2:38.66 |