| N | Meet | 3:52.73 | Iuri Pinto | ESU | 2007 |
| $ | Stadium | 3:50.22 | Rob Berkebile | Shippensburg | 1985 |
| Lane | Athlete | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Shane McKeon | Scranton |
4:02.57 | Muhlenberg Invitational |
| 2 | Timothy Lanahan | Scranton |
4:05.40 | Muhlenberg Invitational |
| 3 | John Amenta | SUNY Delhi |
4:06.31 | ACPHS-Sage-Delhi |
| 4 | Matt Tina | St. Thomas Aquinas |
4:09.37 | Ansin Track & Field Invitational Track Series #2 (DII) |
| 5 | Nicholas Falsone | Unattached | 4:10.00 | |
| 6 | Brian McGarrity | East Stroudsburg |
4:11.49 | 39th Millersville Metrics |
| 7 | Chris Bien-Aime | Adelphi |
4:13.50 | |
| 8 | Justin Allone | Seton Hall |
4:18.37 | 2022 Greyhound Invitational |
| 9 | Christian Snee | Scranton |
4:18.47 | 2022 Messiah Multi/Invitational |
| 10 | Jack Emrey | Franklin & Marshall |
4:20.00 | |
| 11 | DANIEL WASHBURN | Seton Hall |
4:20.00 | |
| 12 | Aiden Watson | Molloy |
4:20.40 | |
| 13 | Michael Dowd | Wilmington (Del.) |
4:20.62 | Danny Curran Invitational |
| 14 | Owen McCann | Franklin & Marshall |
4:25.00 | |
| 15 | Bladimir Pena | SUNY Delhi |
4:26.10 | 2019 Bronco Classic Invitational |
| Lane | Athlete | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jack Terry-Kantor | St. Thomas Aquinas |
4:27.77 | Sharks Invitational Meet |
| 2 | Thomas Bovenberg | St. Thomas Aquinas |
4:31.18 | Ansin Track & Field Invitational Track Series #2 (DII) |
| 3 | NICHOLAS MINIKEL | Seton Hall |
4:31.39 | 2021 Greyhound Invitational |
| 4 | Spencer Milito | 4:33.10 | WCU Golden Ram Invitational | |
| 5 | Allen Lawton | SUNY Delhi |
4:33.34 | Delhi Invite #4 |
| 6 | Dan Gavin | Scranton |
4:35.00 | |
| 7 | Muhammed Qadri | 4:36.01 | TCNJ Invitational | |
| 8 | Daniel Pinilla | 4:39.14 | Vassar College April Invitational | |
| 9 | Caleb Jeralds | SUNY Delhi |
4:43.18 | Delhi Invite #2 |
| 10 | Antonio Solari | 4:48.95 | Osprey Open and Multi | |
| 11 | Alan Bass | 4:49.73 | TCNJ Invitational | |
| 12 | Alex Sakal | Penn State T&F Club | 5:00.00 | |
| 13 | Musa Mazreku | Lehman |
5:01.78 | Misericordia Twilight |
| 14 | Jesusalberto Fernandez | Lehman |
5:03.85 | Vassar College April Invitational |
| 15 | Brendan Solano | East Stroudsburg |
5:20.00 | |
| 16 | Joshua Noble | NT |