| N | Meet | 1:37.90 | Edena Sanchez | Amsterdam | 2016 |
| Athlete | Team | Seed | Note | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Kathleen Sullivan | Lansing | 1:48.32 | Unverified: |
| 2 | Abigail Silva | Lansing | 1:54.21 | Unverified: |
| 3 | Sage Pruskowski | Bainbridge-Guilford/Afton (BGA) | 2:12.00 | Unverified: |
| 4 | Brooklyn MacNaught | Bainbridge-Guilford/Afton (BGA) | 2:17.00 | Unverified: |
| 5 | Emma Vanderhoof | Waverly | NT | Unverified: |
| 6 | Kelsey Ward | Waverly | NT | Unverified: |
| 7 | Maleah Brockington | Oneonta HS | NT | Unverified: |
| 8 | Jaelyn Privitera | Oneonta HS | NT | Unverified: |
| 9 | Anna Lowe | Horseheads | NT | Unverified: |
| 10 | Tabitha Oakes | Horseheads | NT | Unverified: |
| 11 | Gabe Dietzman | Chenango Forks | NT | Unverified: |
| 12 | Olivia Hulse | Walton | NT | Unverified: |
| 13 | Ella Rhinehart | Walton | NT | Unverified: |
| 14 | Gates Jessica | Chenango Valley | NT | Unverified: |
| 15 | Alex Neubert | Sidney Track | NT | Unverified: |