| PL | Squad | Team | Final | Pts | Athlete 1 | Athlete 2 | Athlete 3 | Athlete 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A | Bellarmine | 10:03.17 | 10 | Dotterweich | Klosterman | Findlater | Sandlin |
| 2 | A | Southern Indiana | 10:07.62 | 8 | Schickel | Thomas | Callison | Jordan |
| 3 | A | Indianapolis | 10:22.37 | 6 | O'Brien | Schwartz | O'Boyle | McMillan |
| 4 | A | McKendree | 10:25.53 | 5 | Todd | Wilhelm | Korir | DeLong |
| 5 | A | Wis.-Parkside | 10:29.87 | 4 | Escareno | Armstrong | Rivard | Mikkelson |
| 6 | A | Missouri S&T | 10:33.50 | 3 | Stocker | Neds | Naeger | Marchman |
| 7 | A | Maryville (Mo.) | 10:38.44 | 2 | Allen | Morr | Baltrushunas | Zuniga |
| 8 | A | St. Joseph's (Ind.) | 10:40.73 | 1 | Witt | Galloway | Fauser | Massoels |
| 9 | A | Drury | 10:40.74 | Abernathy | Heffington | Gray | Armstrong | |
| 10 | A | Lewis | 10:56.22 | Tanis | Gallahger | Kolanko | Weissensel | |
| 11 | A | William Jewell | 11:15.14 | Houck | Simmons | Porter | Heady |