| Athlete | Yr | Team | Seed | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Smith, Ryan | SR | Indianapolis | 19.65m |
| 2 | Lovejoy, Tim | JR | Indianapolis | 17.90m |
| 3 | Neff, Jonathan | SR | Bellarmine | 16.68m |
| 4 | Fletcher, Troy | SR | William Jewell | 15.96m |
| 5 | Vellella, Joseph | SO | Missouri S&T | 15.89m |
| 6 | Austin, Alan | SR | St. Joseph's (Ind.) | 15.03m |
| 7 | Barr, Adam | FR | Lewis | 15.00m |
| 8 | Juhas, Nick | JR | Lewis | 15.00m |
| 9 | Pappert, Kris | SR | St. Joseph's (Ind.) | 14.51m |
| 10 | Onwubiko, Godson | JR | Missouri S&T | 14.23m |
| 11 | Ziraldo, Vincent | FR | Indianapolis | 14.01m |
| 12 | Rahar, EJ | JR | McKendree | 13.91m |
| 13 | Cashio, Nicholas | FR | William Jewell | 13.47m |
| 14 | Pena, Ricardo | SR | Lewis | 13.37m |
| 15 | Ellison, Andrew | FR | McKendree | 13.29m |
| 16 | Whisler, Brett | SR | William Jewell | 13.23m |
| 17 | Mull, Stephen | FR | Missouri S&T | 13.22m |
| 18 | Heisler, Cameron | SO | Indianapolis | 13.12m |
| 19 | Fischer, Vincent | FR | St. Joseph's (Ind.) | 12.53m |
| 20 | Pollmann, Eric | FR | McKendree | 11.83m |
| 21 | Ballenger, Zach | SO | Southern Indiana | 11.79m |
| 22 | Logan, Trevor | JR | William Jewell | 11.72m |
| 23 | Mitchell, Dale | SR | Kentucky Wesleyan | 10.92m |
| 24 | Morris, Ricky | SO | Maryville (Mo.) | 9.46m |