| Lane | Team | Squad | Seed | 
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Goshen | A | 4:25.68 | 
| 2 | Findlay | A | 4:08.00 | 
| 3 | Marian (Ind.) | A | 4:04.29 | 
| 4 | Cedarville | A | 3:55.78 | 
| 5 | Indianapolis | A | 3:59.48 | 
| 6 | Olivet Nazarene | B | 4:16.00 | 
| 7 | Marian (Ind.) | B | 4:10.85 | 
| 8 | Indiana East | A | NT | 
| Lane | Team | Squad | Seed | 
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | Marian (Ind.) | C | 4:18.53 | 
| 4 | Olivet Nazarene | A | 4:15.00 | 
| 5 | Indianapolis | B | 4:05.55 | 
| 6 | Marian (Ind.) | D | 4:22.56 |