| Lane | Athlete | Team | Seed |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | BROWN-GORDON, Daniel | NM | |
| 2 | KEENAN, James | Wilmington (Del.) |
NM |
| 3 | COLL, Mitch | Wilmington (Del.) |
23.42m |
| 4 | CHEATON, Jordan | 23.60m | |
| 5 | RIVERA, Jose | West Chester |
27.81m |
| 6 | SMITH, Thomas | West Chester |
29.96m |
| 7 | THORNTON, Ben | West Chester |
31.17m |
| 8 | PALLESCHI, Hartley | Unattached | 38.00m |
| 9 | MEDINA, Geraldo | West Chester |
42.51m |
| 10 | VARGHESE, Josh | Wilmington (Del.) |
47.92m |