| Lane | Athlete | Team | Seed |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | KEIM, Matt | IVC | NM |
| 2 | MILLER, Joshua | Otterbein | NM |
| 3 | REITER, Keith | Unattached | NM |
| 4 | BUTZIN, Steele | Tiffin | 3.49m |
| 5 | WILSON, Garrett | Tiffin | 3.70m |
| 6 | TAYLOR, Andrew | Ohio Northern | 3.85m |
| 7 | WILLIAMS, Brady | Otterbein | 4.16m |
| 8 | SHIPLEY, Tyler | Mount Vernon Nazarene | 4.30m |
| 9 | MARSHALL, Brandt | Ohio Northern | 4.31m |
| 10 | CARTER, Cade | Tiffin | 4.85m |
| 11 | PAINTER, Joe | St. Francis (Ind.) | 4.90m |
| 12 | JASIN, Collin | Tiffin | 5.25m |