| * | Myrtle Beach Collegiate Challenge | 9:06.40 | Scott, Dyke, Greenleaf, Stump | Virginia Commonwealth | 3/11/2016 |
| ! | Doug Shaw Stadium | 8:51.01 | Brooks, Ritter, Swenson, Dittmar | Minnesota | 3/19/2010 |
| Lane | Team | Squad | Athlete 1 | Athlete 2 | Athlete 3 | Athlete 4 | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Clarion |
A | Carver | McDonnell | LaBombard | McDonnell | NT | |
| 2 | Concord |
A | Wallace | Cunningham | O'Sullivan | Altizer | 9:46.59 | Myrtle Beach Collegiate Challenge |
| 3 | Truett-McConnell |
A | Campbell | Chock | Ponce | Owen | 10:26.80 | Appalachian Athletic Conference Track & Field Championships |
| 4 | North Greenville |
A | Justice | Futrell | Gonzalez | Gidney | 10:50.66 | Mondo College Invitational |
| 5 | Col. of Charleston |
A | Harding | McGrew | Kalus | Purves | 9:14.76 | CAA Indoor Track & Field Championships |
| 6 | Citadel |
A | Shea | Cunningham | DeLancy | Melton | 11:05.33 | Weems Baskin Relays |
| 7 | Wilmington (Del.) |
A | Banniing | Banning | Cornejo | Whyte | DNS | |
| 8 | Alderson Broaddus |
A | Bumbry | Colas | Fort | James | NT | |
| 9 | Slippery Rock |
B | Hughes | Valeriano | Rennette | Murtland | NT | |
| 10 | Slippery Rock |
A | Plassio | Hunt | Igims | Wyant | NT |