| * | Myrtle Beach Collegiate Challenge | 3:46.40 | McCoy, Friday, Marton, Mitchell | Seton Hall | 3/10/2007 | 
| ! | Doug Shaw Stadium | 3:36.11 | Bellamy, Haith, Bandy, Homes | South Carolina | 3/22/2014 | 
| Lane | Team | Squad | Athlete 1 | Athlete 2 | Athlete 3 | Athlete 4 | Seed | Note | 
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Alderson Broaddus | 
		A | James | Fort | Washington | Colas | 4:06.20 | Mountain East Conference Indoor Track & Field Championships | 
| 2 |  Messiah | 
		A | Miller | Hamlen | Rickard | Vargas | 4:01.05 | Penn Relays | 
| 3 |  Slippery Rock | 
		A | Veneziano | Rennette | Morgan | Olsen | 3:57.41 | SFU Red Flash Open | 
| 4 |  Coastal Carolina | 
		A | Boon | St. Cyr | Clemens | Kinloch | 3:36.25 | North Florida Collegiate Invitational | 
| 5 |  Slippery Rock | 
		B | Younkin | Johnson | Robinson | Martz | 3:57.41 | SFU Red Flash Open | 
| 6 |  Truett-McConnell | 
		A | Nakanwagi | Allen | Owen | Hall | 3:57.87 | Torrin Lawrence Memorial Invite | 
| 7 |  Col. of Charleston | 
		A | Bailey | Ottomanelli | Fortuna | Purves | 4:05.76 | South Carolina Invitational 2023 | 
| 8 |  Col. of Charleston | 
		B | Kalus | Harding | Smith | McGrew | 4:05.76 | South Carolina Invitational 2023 | 
| Lane | Team | Squad | Athlete 1 | Athlete 2 | Athlete 3 | Athlete 4 | Seed | Note | 
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 |  Wilmington (Del.) | 
		A | Brown | Turner | Whyte | Banniing | 4:23.42 | Penn Relays | 
| 3 |  Piedmont | 
		A | Williams | Ponce | Caccamo | Cates | 4:14.55 | USA South Track & Field Conference Championship | 
| 4 |  Concord | 
		A | Cunningham | Altizer | Davis | Strachan | 4:11.65 | Mountain East Conference Indoor Track & Field Championships | 
| 5 |  Clarion | 
		A | McDonnell | McDonnell | Perry | Carver | 4:12.20 | PSAC Outdoor Track & Field Championships | 
| 6 |  Husson | 
		A | Whitten | Garvey | Goodwin | Hubbard | 4:16.99 | Frozen 8 Indoor Track & Field Championships | 
| 7 |  Concord | 
		B | Jackson | Holmes | Londeree | Dixon | 4:25.00 | Mountain East Conference Indoor Track & Field Championships | 
| 8 | A | Albraihi | Winslow | Redding | Shannon | 4:38.80 | New England DIII Women's Indoor Championships | 
| Lane | Team | Squad | Athlete 1 | Athlete 2 | Athlete 3 | Athlete 4 | Seed | Note | 
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 |  North Greenville | 
		B | Rose | Justice | Irizarry | Vaughn | NT | 2022 Conference Carolinas Track & Field Championships | 
| 4 |  Concord | 
		C | Perry | James | Bentley | Mills | NT | Mountain East Conference Indoor Track & Field Championships | 
| 5 |  Allen | 
		A | Pack | Taylor | Black | Mayes | DNF |