| * | Myrtle Beach Collegiate Challenge | 1:35.46 | Kemp, Friday, Mitchell, Simkins | Seton Hall | 3/12/2010 |
| ! | Doug Shaw Stadium | 1:33.37 | A. Abrams, T. Brockington, B. Haith, M. Dendy | South Carolina | 3/18/2016 |
| Lane | Team | Squad | Athlete 1 | Athlete 2 | Athlete 3 | Athlete 4 | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Slippery Rock |
B | Lamoreaux | Miller | Book | Wyatt | 1:56.00 | Alan Connie Shamrock Invitational |
| 2 | Col. of Charleston |
A | Fortuna | Cucinotta | O'Neill | Alberts | 1:48.31 | Myrtle Beach Collegiate Challenge |
| 3 | Truett-McConnell |
A | Hall | Wilmoth | Nakanwagi | Arnold | 1:45.42 | Myrtle Beach Collegiate Challenge |
| 4 | Slippery Rock |
A | Walasavage | Blauser | Rennette | Bogia | 1:48.00 | Alan Connie Shamrock Invitational |
| 5 | Wilmington (Del.) |
A | Brown | Turner | Whyte | Mustapha | 1:50.32 | Myrtle Beach Collegiate Challenge |
| 6 | Husson |
A | Freeman | Cotoni | Stiles | Hubbard | 1:56.68 | 2023 Maine State Indoor Championships |
| Lane | Team | Squad | Athlete 1 | Athlete 2 | Athlete 3 | Athlete 4 | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Swarthmore |
A | Kirton | Bortz | Kashynski | Boadi | NT | |
| 2 | Allen |
A | Patterson | Moorer | Pack | Jones | NT | |
| 3 | Clarion |
A | Sharrow | Serrano | Snyder | Redwood | 1:57.84 | Mount Union Wuske Open |
| 4 | Citadel |
A | Jackson | Lawrence | Murray | Byrd | NT | |
| 5 | North Greenville |
A | Cox | Hill | Vaughn | Smiling | NT | |
| 6 | Allen |
B | Garbutt | Mayes | Sherman | Taylor | DNS |