| PL | Squad | Team | Final | Pts | Athlete 1 | Athlete 2 | Athlete 3 | Athlete 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | A | Southwestern | 4:00.76 | 10 | Sheppard | Hollenback | Wenrick | Sisneros |
| 2 | A | Sterling | 4:07.06 | 8 | Myers | Simpson | Enfield | Garrett |
| 3 | A | McPherson | 4:09.52 | 6 | McCaffrey | Pleasant | Lowry | Samuels |
| 4 | A | Tabor | 4:09.79 | 5 | Harris | Kemling | Yoder | King |
| 5 | A | Bethany | 4:15.57 | 4 | Gilliland | Martinez | Bosley | Stuewe |
| 6 | A | Friends | 4:16.01 | 3 | Keck | Newlin | Burley | Adams |
| 7 | A | Ottawa | 4:21.57 | 2 | Kessler | Harrington | Bailey | Richardson |
| 8 | A | Saint Mary | 4:32.19 | 1 | clair | Winter | Jystad | Ellis |