| ! | BHWC | 12:29.16 | Schroff, McNamara, Kitsmiller, Vis | John Carroll | 2/23/2024 |
| @ | Muskie Meet #2 | 13:16.40 | Gilles, LaRue, Reid-Vensel, Carr | Washington & Jefferson | 1/20/2024 |
| Lane | Team | Squad | Athlete 1 | Athlete 2 | Athlete 3 | Athlete 4 | Seed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pitt.-Johnstown |
A | Fedor | Menzies | Zuro | Barker | 12:53.88 |
| 2 | Waynesburg |
A | Boothe | Fuller | Ryer | Tanksley | 13:59.85 |
| 3 | WVU Track Club | A | Ludman | Lindley | Harrington | Andrew | NT |