| Athlete | Team | Seed | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | BISHOP, Tyler | Duquesne | 46.68m |
| 2 | CRISS JR, Timothy | Duquesne | 42.29m |
| 3 | REICHER, Louie | Muskingum | 41.64m |
| 4 | SEGURA, Giovanni | Geneva | 40.73m |
| 5 | SPURLOCK, Gabe | Duquesne | 40.50m |
| 6 | TEVROW, Barry | Allegheny | 40.14m |
| 7 | FLOYD, Wade | Muskingum | 39.85m |
| 8 | FABER, Sam | Thiel | 34.95m |
| 9 | JOHNSON, Eric | Muskingum | 34.80m |
| 10 | PARKER, Noah | Allegheny | 34.12m |
| 11 | RIEMERSMA, Steven | Geneva | 31.84m |
| 12 | RICHARDS, Croix | Geneva | 31.02m |
| 13 | TRAMMEL, Colton | Geneva | 30.41m |
| 14 | STRICKLAND, Skylar | Muskingum | 27.85m |
| 15 | MILLER, Nic | Geneva | 27.69m |
| 16 | STALEY, Jeff | Thiel | 25.96m |
| 17 | ALTSMAN, Hunter | Geneva | 23.80m |
| 18 | VALENTINE, Issac | Geneva | 23.31m |
| 19 | GROVER, Greg | Geneva | 20.88m |
| 20 | ODETTE-SPILLNER, Daniel | Muskingum | NM |