| Lane | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ANDRETTA, Troy | JR | Monmouth | 60.86m |
| 2 | TOTH, Travis | SR | East Stroudsburg | 61.63m |
| 3 | LAWLER, Rob | SR | DeSales | 50.39m |
| 4 | FRIEL, Jimmy | Unattached | 38.14m | |
| 5 | SANTARSIERO, Vincent | SO | Monmouth | 50.83m |
| 6 | WILSON, Timothy | SO | Monmouth | 62.23m |
| 7 | SWEITZER, Dan | SO | Lafayette | 44.05m |
| 8 | CARSON, Taylor | JR | Monmouth | 42.73m |
| 9 | MARTIN, George | JR | Monmouth | 51.08m |
| 10 | BEAUCHAMP, Ben | Lehigh Alumni | NM | |
| 11 | SILVERSTEIN, Michael | SO | Muhlenberg | 34.93m |