| MR | Stan Morgan | 4:08.04 | Dalton Hengst | McDonogh | 2017 |
| Lane | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | BUTLER, Dylan | 9 | Boiling Springs | 5:01.24 | Unverified: @Gettysburg 2024 |
| 2 | SKAUGEN, Cole | 9 | East Pennsboro Area | 5:01.85 | Unverified: East Pennsboro vs West Perry |
| 3 | WORKINGER, Carson | 9 | Red Land | 5:07.81 | Unverified: Cedar Cliff Relays |
| 4 | GROW, Austin | 9 | Lower Dauphin | 5:11.55 | Unverified: Lower Dauphin vs Red Land |
| 5 | DUNKEL, Kieran | 9 | Shippensburg | 5:14.32 | Unverified: |
| 6 | WHITE, Matthew | 9 | Trinity 03 | 5:22.01 | Unverified: Trinity HS vs. Camp Hill |
| 7 | MCKEE, Wyatt | 9 | Cumberland Valley | 5:29.53 | Unverified: |
| 8 | AIELLO, Jonathan | 9 | New Oxford | 5:36.73 | Unverified: Ray Geesey Invitational |
| 9 | RAU, Mason | 9 | Lower Dauphin | 5:39.03 | Unverified: Hershey Meet of Champions |
| Lane | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | HEBERT, Brody | 9 | Gettysburg Area | 4:45.74 | Unverified: |
| 2 | TANNEY, Patrick | 9 | Trinity 03 | 4:47.36 | Unverified: Trinity HS vs. Camp Hill |
| 3 | VINCENTI, Boston | 9 | Chambersburg | 4:50.14 | Unverified: State College/Harrisburg |
| 4 | HOKE, Milton | 9 | Cedar Cliff | 4:52.00 | Unverified: CC vs. Hershey |
| 5 | BRETZ, Drew | 9 | Cumberland Valley | 4:54.62 | Unverified: |
| 6 | LANDERS, Nathan | 9 | Mechanicsburg Area | 4:55.03 | Unverified: Hershey Dual Meet |
| 7 | WALTER, Gavin | 9 | Carlisle | 4:58.30 | Unverified: Harrisburg Dual |
| 8 | WENGER, Gavin | 9 | Big Spring | 4:59.84 | Unverified: cy fritz |
| 9 | ASHMAN, Shane | 9 | Trinity 03 | 5:00.06 | Unverified: Trinity HS vs. Camp Hill |