| MR | Stan Morgan | 4:08.04 | Dalton Hengst | McDonogh | 2017 |
| Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | MILLARE, James | SO | Carlisle | 4:22.07 | Verified |
| 2 | SHRADER, Owen | SR | Chambersburg | 4:24.51 | Verified |
| 3 | HEBERLIG, Kolbin | SO | Carlisle | 4:29.35 | Verified |
| 4 | CUMMINGS, Cornelius | SO | Palmyra | 4:30.30 | Verified |
| 5 | KIRKPATRICK, Liam | JR | Chambersburg | 4:32.23 | Verified |
| 6 | PETULA, Connor | SR | Boiling Springs | 4:33.27 | Unverified: @Greencastle 2024 |
| 7 | BLANTON, Joshua | 9 | Carlisle | 4:33.96 | Verified |
| 8 | RIFE, Kaden | JR | Chambersburg | 4:34.90 | Verified |
| 9 | DELANEY, Tyson | 9 | Red Land | 4:37.72 | Verified |
| 10 | ALLEMAN, Aiden | SO | Chambersburg | 4:38.54 | Unverified: CD East |
| 11 | VOTTERO, Jake | SR | Palmyra | 4:38.60 | Verified |
| 12 | GROW, Christian | JR | Lower Dauphin | 4:40.31 | Verified |
| 13 | REICHENBACH, Seth | SO | Carlisle | 4:41.19 | Verified |
| 14 | ERICKSON, Connor | SR | Shippensburg | 4:42.00 | Verified |
| 15 | BEST, Grant | JR | Carlisle | 4:42.34 | Verified |
| 16 | HENRY, Abdi | SR | Lower Dauphin | 4:42.74 | Verified |
| 17 | SCHNEIDER, Rylan | SR | Red Land | 4:43.87 | Verified |
| 18 | KERR, Benjamin | JR | Carlisle | 4:44.06 | Verified |
| 19 | BOCKSTIE, Noah | SR | Waynesboro | 4:45.00 | Unverified: vs GA |
| 20 | DUNKEL, Andreas | JR | Shippensburg | 4:46.08 | Verified |
| 21 | PRICE, Neal | SR | New Oxford | 4:46.20 | Verified |
| 22 | CARNES, Ford | SO | Lower Dauphin | 4:47.13 | Verified |
| 23 | KINTON, Sam | SO | Chambersburg | 4:48.24 | Unverified: CD |
| 24 | BURD, Isaac | JR | Trinity 03 | 4:48.60 | Verified |
| 25 | KEFFER, Logan | SR | Chambersburg | 4:49.24 | Unverified: CD East |
| 26 | FOCHT, Hudson | SO | Carlisle | 4:49.63 | Verified |
| 27 | BRANDENBURG, Cooper | SO | Central Dauphin East | 4:50.82 | Verified |
| 28 | SHANK, Denny | SO | Carlisle | 4:51.00 | Verified |
| 29 | BARGER, Devin | SO | Waynesboro | 4:51.00 | Unverified: vs Shipp |
| 30 | KORCH, Cole | JR | Cedar Cliff | 4:51.32 | Verified |
| 31 | HUERTAS, Alex | SR | Mechanicsburg Area | 4:51.54 | Unverified: Red Land Dual Meet |
| 32 | DIAZ, Elijah | SR | Trinity 03 | 4:52.35 | Verified |
| 33 | BREIGHNER, Luke | JR | Gettysburg Area | 4:52.54 | Unverified: |
| 34 | FORD, Connor | SR | Shippensburg | 4:53.10 | Unverified: |
| 35 | CAMPBELL, Will | JR | Waynesboro | 4:54.00 | Unverified: vs GA |
| 36 | OSHUNRINADE, Nico | 9 | Gettysburg Area | 4:54.94 | Unverified: |