| MR | Stan Morgan | 3:54.58 | Gaines, Burton, Wilkinson, Burton | Susquehanna Twp | 2016 | 
| Team | Squad | Athlete 1 | Athlete 2 | Athlete 3 | Athlete 4 | Seed | Note | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Central Dauphin East | A | Ingram | Bellamy | Livingston | Premici | 4:05.32 | Verified | 
| 2 | Carlisle | A | 4:05.41 | Verified | ||||
| 3 | Waynesboro | A | Ruefle | Briegel | French | Benshoff | 4:14.04 | Unverified: vs GA | 
| 4 | Cedar Cliff | A | Walley | Skokowski | Spamer | Nugin | 4:15.13 | Verified | 
| 5 | Chambersburg | A | Holmes | Hang | Weller | Coy | 4:18.74 | Unverified: | 
| 6 | Boiling Springs | A | Volz | Chamberlin | Delevan | Felix | 4:29.00 | Verified |