| Lane | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | LONG, Jordan | SR | Kennard-Dale | 5:05.24 | @ Eastern York |
| 2 | MYERS, Xander | FR | Dover | 5:05.24 | |
| 3 | THOMSON, Dru | SO | West York Area | 5:07.00 | |
| 4 | MACCARELLI, Chad | JR | Kennard-Dale | 5:07.44 | vs York Suburban |
| 5 | KREBS, Tyler | JR | Dallastown | 5:07.90 | Leonard Stephan Invitational |
| 6 | MILLER, Patrick | SO | Kennard-Dale | 5:07.99 | Blue Jay Invitational |
| 7 | ABELL, Jedi | SO | Hanover High School | 5:08.0h | |
| 8 | CHUNDURU, Avinash | FR | Central York | 5:10.24 | @ Northeastern (2024) |
| 9 | LEASE, Logan | SO | Susquehannock | 5:14.02 | 35th Pan-Ram Invitational |
| 10 | MAYORYK, Stephen | SR | Susquehannock | 5:14.46 | 35th Pan-Ram Invitational |
| 11 | GINGRICH, Carter | FR | York Suburban | 5:15.24 | YS @ SQ 4-9-24 |
| 12 | BISHOP, Khaydin | SO | Hanover High School | 5:20.0h | |
| 13 | MWANGI, Ryan | SO | Central Dauphin | 5:21.33 | Central Dauphin vs CD East vs Ha |
| 14 | SMITH, Orien | FR | York County School of Tech | 5:22.42 | 35th Pan-Ram Invitational |
| 15 | MILLER, Gavin | SO | New Oxford | 5:22.55 | The Miller Sports Construction B |
| 16 | SANTIAGO-VEGA, Dominic | SO | Donegal | 5:25.74 | Twin Valley Invitational |
| 17 | URRUNAGA, Christopher | SR | West York Area | 5:26.00 | |
| 18 | WACHTMAN, Parker | SO | Central Dauphin | 5:27.70 | Central Dauphin vs CD East vs Ha |
| 19 | AIELLO, Jonathan | FR | New Oxford | 5:39.04 | The Miller Sports Construction B |
| 20 | DIVINEY, Cole | FR | New Oxford | 5:55.0h | NO vs YS |
| Lane | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | NAYLOR, Daniel | JR | Red Lion | 4:28.88 | YAIAA Track and Field Championsh |
| 2 | FISHER, Conor | JR | Emmaus | 4:33.97 | Colonial League and EPAC Champio |
| 3 | WISNIEWSKI, Cian | SO | Red Lion | 4:36.40 | Shippensburg 97th Roddick HS Inv |
| 4 | FINCK, Tyler | SR | Emmaus | 4:37.00 | Emmaus vs Whitehall |
| 5 | ROSKOVENSKY, Jacob | FR | Dallastown | 4:39.14 | Leonard Stephan Invitational |
| 6 | STRICKLER, Austin | SR | Central York | 4:43.14 | @ Dallastown (2024) |
| 7 | TEDESCO, Nathan | SO | York Suburban | 4:43.64 | YS @ KD 4-23 |
| 8 | MILLER, Steven | SR | West York Area | 4:44.00 | |
| 9 | KEISER, Parker | JR | Red Lion | 4:46.15 | YAIAA Track and Field Championsh |
| 10 | MILLER, Connor | SR | Emmaus | 4:47.10 | Emmaus vs Whitehall |
| 11 | SNYDER, Harrison | SR | Central Dauphin | 4:52.29 | Central Dauphin vs Harrisburg vs |
| 12 | ROSUL, Robert | SR | Susquehannock | 4:54.24 | Maverick Madness 5 |
| 13 | GIBSON, Zachary | SR | South Western | 4:55.64 | Red Lion |
| 14 | UREY, Nicholas | SO | York County School of Tech | 4:57.00 | Littlestown |
| 15 | FIVES, Joshua | SO | Central York | 4:57.24 | @ Northeastern (2024) |
| 16 | DIAMOND, Ethan | JR | South Western | 4:58.74 | Red Lion |
| 17 | ROMYN, Alexander | SO | Dallastown | 4:59.68 | Leonard Stephan Invitational |
| 18 | GAIDOS, Adam | SO | York County School of Tech | 5:02.07 | Breslin Invitational at Mount Ca |
| 19 | FUHRMAN, Brody | SR | South Western | 5:04.44 | Northeastern |