| Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | QUINAN, Garrett | SO | Shippensburg |
8:33.14 | Sykes & Sabock Challenge |
| 2 | CRUM, Tommy | FR | Shippensburg |
8:38.73 | PSAC Indoor Track & Field Championship |
| 3 | WOLFE, Ryan | SO | Shippensburg |
8:45.61 | Paul Kaiser Classic |
| 4 | WELLOCK, Brennan | SO | Shippensburg |
8:51.50 | Gulden Invitational 2024 |
| 5 | SCHABENER, Cody | SO | Kutztown |
8:56.43 | Bison Outdoor Classic |
| 6 | GONDER, Aiden | JR | Shippensburg |
8:58.51 | Paul Kaiser Classic |
| 7 | GREEN, Dillon | FR | Indiana (Pa.) |
9:25.17 | SPIRE Indoor Games 2024 |
| 8 | BRAUGHT, Kaiden | Unattached | 9:30.00 | ||
| 9 | HAZEN, Jackson | JR | Messiah |
9:55.44 | Bucknell Tune Up |
| 10 | ALLARDYCE, Michael | FR | Scranton |
10:01.52 | 2024 Bomber Invitational |
| 11 | MORRIS, Jackson | FR | Scranton |
10:23.36 | Conference Challenge Cup |
| 12 | SEEBODE, Luke | SO | CCBC Essex |
10:25.49 | Paul Kaiser Classic |
| 13 | LOMOTAN, Owen | Penn State T&F Club | NT | NT | |
| 14 | SCHMIDT, Dylan | Maryland Club Running | NT | 9:15 | |
| 15 | WEHRLE, Matthew | SR | 24/11 Track Club | NT | 8:50 |