| Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ENDRES, Samuel | SR | State College | 4:24.20 | Verified |
| 2 | SHRADER, Owen | SR | Chambersburg | 4:24.75 | Verified |
| 3 | SNYDER, Ari | SR | Chambersburg | 4:24.91 | Verified |
| 4 | COUGHLIN, Owen | JR | State College | 4:25.74 | Verified |
| 5 | OPPERMANN, Isaac | JR | State College | 4:28.18 | Verified |
| 6 | FOWLER, Stephen | JR | State College | 4:28.70 | Verified |
| 7 | BARABAS, Eli | SR | State College | 4:33.90 | Verified |
| 8 | KIRKPATRICK, Liam | JR | Chambersburg | 4:34.30 | Verified |
| 9 | KEFFER, Logan | SR | Chambersburg | 4:53.90 | Verified |
| 10 | VINCENTI, Boston | 9 | Chambersburg | 4:54.53 | Verified |
| 11 | LAFRAZZA-SCHWARTZ, Vincent | JR | State College | 4:57.78 | Verified |
| 12 | GOSHORN, Aden | SO | Chambersburg | 5:00.80 | Verified |
| 13 | BAILEY, Remmington | JR | State College | 5:10.00 | Verified |
| 14 | STEPAN, Isaac | SO | Chambersburg | 5:11.24 | Unverified: Mifflin County |
| 15 | KINTON, Sam | SO | Chambersburg | 5:12.95 | Verified |
| 16 | EARLE, Isaiah | SR | State College | 5:14.69 | Verified |
| 17 | KEATH, Owen | SO | Chambersburg | 5:29.93 | Verified |