| # | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 81 | HODGE, Aidan | SR | Hempfield (3) | 4:12.51 | Verified |
| 2 | 82 | FREEDMAN, Sam | JR | Hempfield (3) | 4:25.57 | Verified |
| 3 | 122 | FAHRNEY, Joseph | SR | Hempfield (3) | 4:28.23 | Verified |
| 4 | 89 | LONG, Emerson | JR | Hempfield (3) | 4:40.00 | Verified |
| 5 | 84 | ASHBA, Spencer | 9 | Hempfield (3) | 4:47.36 | Verified |
| 6 | 88 | MEYER, Sam | SO | Hempfield (3) | 4:47.88 | Verified |
| 7 | 123 | WEIDLER, Troy | SO | Warwick | 4:51.11 | Verified |
| 8 | 91 | CHRISTOFFEL, Frank | SR | Hempfield (3) | 4:53.32 | Verified |
| 9 | 95 | CHRISTOFFEL, Patrick | 9 | Hempfield (3) | 5:01.11 | Verified |
| 10 | 96 | HORNBERGER, Riley | SR | Hempfield (3) | 5:08.28 | Verified |
| 11 | 94 | ROY, Everett | JR | Hempfield (3) | 5:08.47 | Verified |
| 12 | 92 | ROY, Miles | JR | Hempfield (3) | 5:12.75 | Verified |
| 13 | 124 | BEAR, Matthew | SR | Warwick | 5:33.42 | Verified |
| 14 | 125 | ADAMSON, Jacob | SO | Warwick | 5:33.85 | Verified |
| 15 | 93 | VAN GROUW, Austin | 9 | Warwick | 5:56.83 | Verified |
| 16 | 98 | WIDDERS, Chase | SO | Warwick | 6:11.27 | Verified |