| R | MAC Outdoor Champ | 51.69m | Knut Hjeltness | Western Maryland | 1973 |
| MAC Outdoor Overall | 52.92m | Frank Schubert | Lehigh | 1954 |
| Lane | # | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 253 | MILLER, Dustin | SR | Hood |
37.41m | 37.41m 40th Millersville Metrics |
| 2 | 391 | RIVERA-JUSINO, Giovanni | FR | Alvernia |
38.43m | 38.43m Shippensburg University College Mid-Week Meet |
| 3 | 688 | FOX, Brandon | SO | Stevens |
38.53m | 38.53m 2023 Coach Pollard Invitational |
| 4 | 616 | BORDOVSKY, Nick | FR | York (Pa.) |
38.30m | 38.30m Paul Kaiser Classic |
| 5 | 506 | LITTLEFIELD, Alden | SR | Widener |
37.44m | 37.44m WCU Golden Ram Invitational |
| 6 | 756 | CHINN, Nick | SR | DeSales |
37.19m | 37.19m 2023 Coach Pollard Invitational |
| 7 | 698 | VEGA, Emmanuel | FR | Stevens |
35.66m | 35.66m King's College Monarch Open |
| 8 | 116 | BROWN, Brayden | FR | Misericordia |
36.60m | 36.60m Misericordia Twilight 2023 |
| 9 | 673 | KEADY, Colin | JR | Stevens |
36.55m | 36.55m 2023 Coach Pollard Invitational |
| 10 | 565 | NOBLIT, Adam | SO | York (Pa.) |
36.45m | 36.45m Shippensburg University College Mid-Week Meet |
| 11 | 837 | DALTON, Ryan | FR | 35.74m | 35.74m Cortland Upstate Alternative | |
| 12 | 327 | JENNINGS, Jaden | SO | Stevenson |
38.78m | 38.78m York College Twilight Meet |
| 13 | 771 | SCHAEFFER, Jacob | FR | DeSales |
35.32m | 35.32m Dr. Jack M. Toms Alumni Invitational |
| Lane | # | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 501 | WARE, Jared | SO | Widener |
47.45m | 47.45m 2023 Widener Invite |
| 2 | 326 | WILLIAMS, Nathan | JR | Stevenson |
48.67m | 48.67m 2023 Danny Curran Invitational |
| 3 | 619 | WENTZ, Gavin | FR | York (Pa.) |
42.50m | 42.50m 2023 Danny Curran Invitational |
| 4 | 575 | MOTT, Andrew | JR | York (Pa.) |
49.08m | 49.08m 2023 Danny Curran Invitational |
| 5 | 850 | KEMP, Carnell | SO | 44.29m | 44.29m King's College Monarch Open | |
| 6 | 483 | JUSINO, Christian | SR | Albright |
41.91m | 41.91m Muhlenberg Outdoor Invitational |
| 7 | 494 | KRISTELLER, Alex | SO | Widener |
42.16m | 42.16m 2023 Danny Curran Invitational |
| 8 | 609 | SHARP, Harrison | JR | York (Pa.) |
45.78m | 45.78m Bison Outdoor Classic |
| 9 | 449 | PEROT, Brandon | SO | Delaware Valley |
41.66m | 41.66m Carol and John Covert Classic |
| 10 | 757 | LAPSZYNSKI, Erik | JR | DeSales |
40.20m | 40.20m 2023 Coach Pollard Invitational |
| 11 | 35 | HETRICK, Wyatt | FR | Lebanon Valley |
40.09m | 40.09m 40th Millersville Metrics |
| 12 | 317 | TERESI, Joseph | SO | 39.60m | 39.60m Oscar Moore Invitational 2023 | |
| 13 | 219 | LECHTHALER, Hoyt | SO | Messiah |
39.56m | 39.56m 2023 Messiah Multi/Invitational |
| 14 | 606 | ROLLINSON, Aidan | FR | York (Pa.) |
38.79m | 38.79m Blue & Gold Goucher Classic |