| MR | MAC Indoor Champ | 4:13.63 | Macharia Yuot | Widener | 2006 |
| OR | MAC Indoor Overall | 4:10.24 | Russell Speiden | Elizabethtown | 2011 |
| Lane | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | CARDIE, Joseph | SR | Widener |
4:31.71 | 4:31.71 Keogh Invitational 2023 |
| 2 | COLYER, Zeke | FR | Messiah |
4:33.45 | 4:33.45 SU Tune Up |
| 3 | KETTULA, John | SO | York (Pa.) |
4:35.37 | 4:35.37 2023 Moravian Indoor Meet |
| 4 | SHELTON, Eric | SO | Lebanon Valley |
4:35.81 | 4:35.81 SU Tune Up |
| 5 | CONNELL, Tim | JR | DeSales |
4:35.86 | 4:35.86 Marc Deneault Invitational 2023 |
| 6 | JUTRAS, Daniel | FR | Stevens |
4:35.92 | 4:35.92 West Point Tune Up |
| 7 | BRICKER, Thomas | FR | Misericordia |
4:36.55 | 4:36.55 Alvernia University Plex Shootout |
| 8 | HUNT, Tyler | SO | York (Pa.) |
4:36.68 | 4:36.68 Blue & White Invite @ F&M |
| 9 | ROSEBOOM, Jack | SO | York (Pa.) |
4:37.51 | 4:37.51 Blue & White Invite @ F&M |
| 10 | ONODY, Bryan | SO | Stevens |
4:38.11 | 4:38.11 Nazareth Conference Challenge Cup |
| 11 | ZAMICHIELI, Dante | SO | Albright |
4:38.63 | 4:38.63 Coach I Open |
| Lane | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | HORST, Logan | JR | Messiah |
4:19.40 | 4:19.40% (4:16.12) Penn State Tune-Up |
| 2 | FETTER, Louka | FR | Messiah |
4:21.53 | 4:21.53% (4:18.22) Penn State Tune-Up |
| 3 | MELAO, Ronnie | JR | Stevens |
4:21.85 | 4:21.85 Nazareth Conference Challenge Cup |
| 4 | HUTCHINSON, Andrew | JR | Messiah |
4:21.87 | 4:21.87% (4:18.56) Penn State Tune-Up |
| 5 | CALISTI, Noah | SO | Messiah |
4:23.16 | 4:23.16% (4:19.83) Penn State Tune-Up |
| 6 | RHINEHART, Trey | SO | Misericordia |
4:24.61 | 4:24.61 Kane Invitational 2023 |
| 7 | MILLAR, David | JR | Widener |
4:25.00 | 4:25.00 Seamus McElligott Invitational 2023 |
| 8 | ARTIS, Shane | JR | DeSales |
4:25.31 | 4:25.31% (4:21.95) NYU DIII Invitational |
| 9 | FLEAR, Thomas | SO | Widener |
4:26.11 | 4:26.11 2023 Moravian Indoor Meet |
| 10 | SAPPE, Chris | FR | Hood |
4:27.46 | 4:27.46 Alvernia University Plex Shootout |
| 11 | AYLMER, Jake | SO | Stevens |
4:28.85 | 4:28.85% (4:25.45) 2023 Boston University David Hemery Valentine Invite |
| 12 | MOYER, Josiah | JR | Messiah |
4:29.04 | 4:29.04% (4:25.64) Penn State Tune-Up |