| Lane | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | KODURU, Aakash | JR | Mercersburg Academy | 4:31.62 | Verified |
| 2 | MAY, Van | SO | Bedford | 4:38.61 | Verified |
| 3 | PATTON, Alex | JR | Wyalusing Valley Area | 4:39.07 | Verified |
| 4 | FISCUS, Sean | JR | Mercersburg Academy | 4:42.62 | Verified |
| 5 | VITUSZYNSKI, Josh | SR | Mid Valley Sr. High School | 4:43.90 | Verified |
| 6 | LOY, Andrew | SR | Greenwood | 4:44.51 | Unverified: Jim Taylor invite |
| 7 | MAVRETIC, Jacob | JR | Millersburg | 4:45.96 | Verified |
| 8 | WHITCOMB, John | JR | Fairfield Area | 4:46.79 | Verified |
| 9 | NEWTON, Logan | JR | Wyalusing Valley Area | 4:50.78 | Unverified: |
| 10 | SCHUBRING, Gabriel | 9 | Fairfield Area | 4:53.95 | Verified |
| 11 | CROWELL, Ryan | SO | Trinity (3) | 4:54.81 | Unverified: Dual Meet |
| 12 | MICHINA, Logan | SO | Penn Cambria | 4:59.48 | Verified |
| 13 | RICE, Glenn | JR | Greenwood | 5:04.24 | Unverified: |
| 14 | SCHERMERHORN, Kyle | JR | Tulpehocken | 5:07.07 | Verified |