| Lane | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | LICHT, Jake | FR | Dickinson | 23.37m | Little 3 Championship |
| 2 | ERICSSON, Daniel | SR | Immaculata | 26.86m | 37th Millersville Metrics |
| 3 | NORWOOD, Jackie | SR | Neumann | 29.02m | Bill Butler Invitational |
| 4 | YOSHIDA, Max | SR | Dickinson | 29.08m | 2019 Messiah Multi/Invitational |
| 5 | VILLARREAL, Francisco | SR | Dickinson | 29.27m | Little 3 Championship |
| 6 | WEST, Alex | JR | McDaniel | 30.95m | Centennial Conference Outdoor Track & Field Championships |
| 7 | LOTZ, James | SO | Dickinson | 31.79m | Muhlenberg Invitational |
| 8 | KIMMEL, Ellis | JR | Dickinson | 33.36m | Little 3 Championship |
| 9 | HARTMAN, Brock | SO | Dickinson | 34.81m | Little 3 Championship |
| 10 | ZIGARELLI, Zachary | FR | Messiah | 36.03m | 37th Millersville Metrics |
| 11 | PILAWSKI, Christian | FR | Messiah | 36.24m | Danny Curran Invitational |
| 12 | VALDEZ, Alejandro | FR | Georgian Court | 36.34m | Rider Invitational 2019 |
| 13 | VILLAREAL, Nick | SO | McDaniel | 37.00m | |
| 14 | DYRLI, Erik | SR | Messiah | 38.13m | 38.13m 2018 Messiah Multi/Invitational |
| 15 | WEYANT, Lars | SO | PSU-Harrisburg | 38.48m | 38.48m 2018 Mason-Dixon Invitational |
| Lane | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | PHILLIPS, Thayer | SO | Juniata | 39.41m | Jim Taylor Invite |
| 2 | GIERINGER, Jacob | SO | Shippensburg | 130' 0" | |
| 3 | QUATSE, Nicolas | FR | Georgian Court | 40.00m | |
| 4 | BEAR, Brooks | FR | Shippensburg | 40.29m | 37th Millersville Metrics |
| 5 | HERBSTER, Joshua | FR | Shippensburg | 40.65m | 37th Millersville Metrics |
| 6 | HEWITT, Tyler | SR | Shippensburg | 140' 0" | |
| 7 | CIVETTA, Antonio | SR | Shippensburg | 43.71m | Bison Outdoor Classic |
| 8 | BASS, Troy | JR | Georgian Court | 45.21m | |
| 9 | MALONEY, Patrick | FR | Shippensburg | 150' 0" | |
| 10 | MORENO, Yobani | FR | Shippensburg | 150' 0" | |
| 11 | LOEH, Matthew | SO | Bloomsburg | 46.28m | Hopkins Loyola Invitational |
| 12 | MARROW, Darius | SO | Georgian Court | 47.50m | 37th Millersville Metrics |
| 13 | ROGER, Ryan | SO | Georgian Court | 48.97m | 24th Annual Monmouth Season Opener |
| 14 | GOLDSBOROUGH, William | FR | Georgian Court | 49.22m | 24th Annual Monmouth Season Opener |
| 15 | STROHE, Cam | JR | Shippensburg | 50.46m | Bison Outdoor Classic |
| 16 | YON, Cameron | SR | PSU-Harrisburg | 56.27m | Jim Taylor Invite |