| Athlete | Yr | Team | Seed | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Burkett, Dylan | SR | Salisbury | 49.37m |
| 2 | Jordan, Jeff | SR | Salisbury | 48.96m |
| 3 | Ballas, Blake | JR | Rowan | 48.85m |
| 4 | Begen, Michael | SO | Ramapo | 46.05m |
| 5 | O'Brien, Ian | SO | York (Pa.) | 44.25m |
| 6 | Baker, Steve | JR | CCNY | 43.79m |
| 7 | Volz, Andrew | SO | Salisbury | 42.98m |
| 8 | Shilling, Ryan | SO | Wesley | 39.99m |
| 9 | Council, Darin | SO | Bridgewater (Va.) | 39.48m |
| 10 | Dygos, James | FR | Ramapo | 39.26m |
| 11 | Mills, Don | SO | Bridgewater (Va.) | 38.30m |
| 12 | Scanlon, Chris | FR | Wesley | 38.00m |
| 13 | Scotto, Joseph | FR | Ramapo | 34.95m |
| 14 | Semper, Aaron | SO | Ramapo | 33.89m |
| 15 | Mitchell, Emmanuel | SO | Howard CC | 32.26m |
| 16 | Mejia, Jeckesan | SO | CCNY | 30.94m |
| 17 | Rodgers, Cameron | FR | Ramapo | NM |
| 18 | Foley, Harrison | FR | CCNY | NM |
| 19 | Beauford, Terez | Unattached | NM |