| Lane | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1A | Clara, Emilio | Chicago (Schurz) | 5:28.42 | ||
| 1B | Alonzo, Alejandro | Chicago (Steinmetz) | 5:22.86 | ||
| 1C | Prado, Bradley | Chicago (Prosser) | 5:15.00 | ||
| 1D | Ezra, Chavez | Chicago (Steinmetz) | 5:11.29 | ||
| 1E | Garcia, Jonathan | Chicago (Taft) | 5:04.74 | ||
| 1F | Powers, Sean | Chicago (Taft) | 4:58.70 | ||
| 1G | Costello, Vince | Chicago (Lane) | 4:55.65 | ||
| 2A | Junco, Juan | Chicago (Schurz) | DNS | ||
| 2B | Fernandez, Jorge | Chicago (Von Steuben) | 5:23.59 | ||
| 2C | Macias, Emmanuel | Chicago (Prosser) | DNS | ||
| 2D | Pillsbury, Charlie | Chicago (Payton) | 5:12.00 | ||
| 2E | Zimny-Schmitt, Ryan | Chicago (St. Patrick) | 5:10.14 | ||
| 2F | Dawson, Jhon Michael | Maywood (Proviso East) | 5:04.70 | ||
| 2G | Resendez, Jesse | Chicago (St. Patrick) | 4:55.67 | ||
| 2H | Zhagui, Kevin | Chicago (Lincoln Park) | 4:55.35 |
| Lane | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1A | Detmer, Sam | Chicago (Payton) | 4:45.00 | ||
| 1B | Ortega, Mariano | Chicago (Lincoln Park) | 4:40.79 | ||
| 1C | Lewis, Vince | Chicago (St. Ignatius Col | 4:35.86 | ||
| 1D | Moreno, Nico | Chicago (Jones) | 4:31.44 | ||
| 1E | Marcos, Jaime | Chicago (Von Steuben) | 4:27.57 | ||
| 1F | Mendez, Clayton | Chicago (Whitney Young) | 4:23.46 | ||
| 1G | Monaghan, Jack | Oak Park (O.P.-River Fore | 4:20.27 | ||
| 2A | Perez, Audiel | Chicago (Mather) | 4:41.44 | ||
| 2B | Pruitt, KC | Chicago (Lane) | 4:40.58 | ||
| 2C | Merten, Nikolas | Chicago (Jones) | 4:33.34 | ||
| 2D | Yemane, Robel | Chicago (Mather) | 4:27.96 | ||
| 2E | Sandberg, Charles | Chicago (Whitney Young) | 4:27.16 | ||
| 2F | Santino, Dan | Chicago (St. Ignatius Col | 4:22.89 | ||
| 2G | Loud, Irwin | Oak Park (O.P.-River Fore | 4:15.47 |