| # | Meet Recod | 9:43.54 | A Salt, B Ehrman, K Krasich, H Beard | Westfield | 2005 |
| Lane | Team | Squad | Athlete 1 | Athlete 2 | Athlete 3 | Athlete 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Penn | A | Mbianda | Balinnang | Morgan | Eubank |
| 2 | Hamilton Southeastern | A | Kepner | Irish | Lammie | Herman |
| 3 | Center Grove | A | Veleta | Cohen | Meisberger | Kemerling |
| 4 | North Central (Indianapolis) | A | Eynon | Fernhaber | Mallon | Rehmel |
| 5 | Warren Central | A | Nouel | Lugo | Tunstill | Sanders |
| 6 | Lawrence North | A | Pittman | Neberieza | Bouton | Strelow |
| 7 | Ft. Wayne Northrop | A | Crews | Schoenle | Valencia | Wilson |
| 8 | Pike | A | Dolson | Olasupo | Mouton | Allen |