| Lane | Athlete | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DOUGLAS, DESHAWN | COWLEY COLLEGE | 2:02.00 | |
| 2 | ALMENDAREZ, JUSTIN | OKLAHOMA WESLEYAN |
2:02.09 | 2023 Tabor Invite |
| 3 | BLANKENSHIP, ANDREW | NEOSHO COUNTY CC | 2:02.21 | Friends University Spring Invitational |
| 4 | HILL, HUNTER | NEOSHO COUNTY CC | 2:02.95 | |
| 5 | BELLOR-GARDNER, LUIS | SOUTHWESTERN (KAN.) |
2:05.82 | 2023 Tabor Invite |
| 6 | REED, TAYLOR | NEOSHO COUNTY CC | 2:06.26 | |
| 7 | VANNUCCHI, GABE | SOUTHWESTERN (KAN.) |
2:06.79 | 2023 Tabor Invite |
| 8 | ELGIN, MESERET | SOUTHWESTERN (KAN.) |
2:08.00 | |
| 9 | MORGAN, NICK | BETHEL (KAN.) |
2:08.54 | 2023 Tabor Invite |
| 10 | FLECK, MATTHEW | BETHEL (KAN.) |
2:08.76 | Southwestern Jinx Inv |
| 11 | DANDU, AJAY | UNATTACHED | 2:10.00 | |
| 12 | ITO, RYOTARO | COFFEYVILLE CC | 2:12.13 | Pittsburg State University Tune-Up |
| 13 | EVANS, TYLER | NEOSHO COUNTY CC | 2:18.59 | Grizzly Classic |
| Lane | Athlete | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | CONDER, ISAAC | COFFEYVILLE CC | 1:52.99 | 15th Annual David Suenram Gorilla Classic |
| 2 | BARTEL, ISAIAH | BETHEL (KAN.) |
1:55.80 | NAIA Indoor Track & Field Championships |
| 3 | ROJAS-MENDEZ, RANDY | COWLEY COLLEGE | 1:56.50 | |
| 4 | HART, JOHNNY | COFFEYVILLE CC | 1:58.22 | 15th Annual David Suenram Gorilla Classic |
| 5 | GKANTATSIOS, DIMITRIOS | UNATTACHED | 1:59.10 | |
| 6 | SCHAEFFER, AUSTIN | SOUTHWESTERN (KAN.) |
1:59.17 | 2023 Tabor Invite |
| 7 | RUIZ, ANDREW | NEOSHO COUNTY CC | 2:00.16 | Pittsburg State University Tune-Up |
| 8 | BROWNFIELD, TYSHAWN | SOUTHWESTERN (KAN.) |
2:00.43 | Friends University Spring Invitational |
| 9 | ALVAREZ, BRYAN | COFFEYVILLE CC | 2:00.72 | 15th Annual David Suenram Gorilla Classic |
| 10 | WISE, TOBIN | BETHEL (KAN.) |
2:00.90 | 2023 Coyote Distance Carnival |
| 11 | SCHMIDT, LUKE | BETHEL (KAN.) |
2:01.53 | Southwestern Jinx Inv |
| 12 | HARDEN, JAI | COFFEYVILLE CC | 2:01.69 | Pittsburg State University Tune-Up |