| PL | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Mark |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Erisman, Tanner | JR | Franklin & Marshall | 53.12m |
| 2 | Galassi, Joseph | FR | Catholic | 52.10m |
| 3 | Harrigan, Conor | SO | Finger Lakes CC | 41.99m |
| 4 | Rivard, Samuel | FR | Catholic | 41.48m |
| 5 | Jernigan, Wade | SR | Virginia Wesleyan | 40.54m |
| 6 | Sloan, Aaron | Unattached | 39.44m | |
| 7 | Mooney, Colin | FR | Mary Washington | 38.84m |
| 8 | Tres, Michael | SO | Virginia Wesleyan | 34.99m |
| 9 | Ortiz, Christian | FR | Virginia Wesleyan | 28.70m |
| Carroll, James | SO | Catholic | NM |