| Lane | Athlete | Yr. | Team | Seed | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | CIUFFA, Aiden | FR | Lindenwood | 4.00m | Illini Challenge and Multi |
| 2 | DAVID QUILLIN, Paul | Harding | 4.34m | ||
| 3 | NIRELLA, Isaac | Harding | 4.40m | ||
| 4 | HENDRIX, Michael | FR | Wis.-Parkside | 4.42m | Parkside Classic |
| 5 | BISSELL, Jon | SR | SE Missouri | 4.45m | 2021 Joey Haines Invite |
| 6 | READNOUR, Isaac | JR | SE Missouri | 4.50m | OVC Indoor Track & Field Championships |
| 7 | ARORA, Daksh | JR | Wis.-Parkside | 4.57m | Parkside Classic |
| 8 | GLEASON, Sullivan | FR | SE Missouri | 4.57m | 2023 Redhawks Invite |
| 9 | ROYE, Dyson | FR | Southern Illinois | 4.61m | Don DeNoon Invite |
| 10 | COUSINS, Kevin | SO | Lewis | 4.70m | Windy City Classic |
| 11 | BEERS, Colin | FR | SE Missouri | 4.72m | 2023 Redhawks Invite |
| 12 | KOONTZ, Tanner | FR | SE Missouri | 4.75m | OVC championship |
| 13 | WALL, John | Harding | 4.92m | ||
| 14 | FERRIS, Ben | Harding | 5.01m | ||
| 15 | O'CONNOR, Drew | Unattached | 5.30m |